Are You Part of the Melanesian Family? – findings from a telephone poll

As leaders gather in Fiji this week for the Melanesian Spearhead Group (MSG) Leaders Summit, the Pacific Institute of Public Policy (PiPP) has released its findings from the first ever telephone poll conducted across Melanesia.

Seven questions relating to the “Melanesian family” of nations were posed, including one asking which major “non Pacific island” nation was considered to be the best partner for individual nations in the region.

MSG leaders may be encouraged that a majority (74.9%) of respondents were aware of the regional body to represent Melanesians.

When asked who they considered part of the Melanesian family, a clear majority of respondents included the established members (PNG, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Fiji and New Caledonia) while 42% also included West Papua, 17.1% included Australia, 14.9% included Indonesia and 14.1% included Timor Leste.

Another question posed was “do you support independence for West Papua?” A clear majority of respondents across Melanesia said yes, with very high support in PNG (89.3%) and Vanuatu (88.2%). This suggests a disconnect between popular support and the position taken by governments in the region, except Vanuatu, which has long championed the West Papuan cause at the political level.

Asked to relate the relationship between their country and Australia, the majority of respondents said it was positive except those in Fiji. Australia is also considered to be the best external partner for PNG (40.5%) and the Solomons (40.4%), while for Vanuatu only 14.1% of respondents considered Australia best, whereas China scored 32.9%. Among respondents in Fiji there was a sense that it considered Australia, New Zealand, China and US as all roughly equal in importance.

In relation to engagement with Fiji, a majority of respondents including those in Fiji itself, opted for increased engagement or keeping the level of engagement as it is.

The views expressed by the respondents of this poll may assist MSG leaders as they deliberate on the future of this region. A copy of the poll findings can be downloaded here.

 The Pacific Institute of Public Policy is the region’s leading independent think tank and exists to stimulate and support informed policy debate.

For further information please contact Talita on +678 29842 or


7 thoughts on “Are You Part of the Melanesian Family? – findings from a telephone poll

  1. This just shows how out-of-step the Melanesian Spearhead Group Leaders and the Secretariat are. They need to stop talking and listen more to the people of the Pacific.

    West Papua is supported overwhelmingly in the region, and the cause of West Papua against Indonesia, who are responsible for human rights violations, murder and rape. Yet here is MSG letting Indonesia in to join!

    And then they always complain “big brother” about Australia. But 17% think Australia is part of the melaneisan family, and many that Australia is the best external partner for Melanesia. Only leaders think badly about Australia, not real people. Maybe that is because Australia does not let them do whatever they want.

    People of the Pacific are sick of being treated badly while leaders make political points. They must listen to us.

  2. This poll has no methodology, asks leading questions and has a tiny sample size – no credible organisation/jounalist would use the results unless they were unaware of the imortance of quality research and polling. Really disappointing to see PiPP, which is funded by AusAID, produce such poor research and promote it as fact.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s